Former nuclear submariner asks: ‘Why Trident?’

New book published by Commander Rob Forsyth RN (Ret’d)

“The theory of nuclear deterrence is flawed, unproven and poses significant dangers from accidental use.”

Commander Robert Forsyth

Commander Rob Forsyth RN (Ret’d), former Executive Officer of the Polaris missile submarine HMS Repulse in the 1970s, was one of the front-line custodians of the UK’s nuclear deterrent at the height of the Cold War.

In common with a number of his peers, Commander Forsyth has grown increasingly concerned about the state into which the Royal Navy has declined as a result of successive cuts in spending. Whilst spending has been cut on conventional forces, one part of the budget has continued to grow – the proportion spent on maintaining the UK’s nuclear deterrent.

Following extensive research, now published in the book Why Trident? (Spokesman, 2020), Commander Forsyth concludes: “Some serious questions need to be asked by the national political and military leadership about not only the affordability, but also the necessity, of the UK’s nuclear deterrent.”

Commander Forsyth has journeyed from the depths of the Cold War and acceptance of ‘nuclear deterrence’ to a rejection of that concept and opposition to renewal of the Trident nuclear weapon system.

His new book details this journey, reveals the findings of his research and stands as a testament to what can be unleashed when the “habit of conformity” is eroded and a determined search for answers is embarked upon.

In his foreword to the book, Vice Admiral Sir Jeremy Blackham KCB MA, writes: “Few people have examined more rigorously the critical questions surrounding the nuclear element of [the] ‘continuum of deterrence’ than Rob Forsyth. I am very glad that his work in this field has been collected into this book. All those involved in this field should read and carefully reflect on what he has to say.”

In his introduction to the book, Professor Nick Grief (Emeritus Professor of Law at the University of Kent and an Associate Tenant at Doughty Street Chambers) writes: “What comes through from Commander Forsyth’s personal reflections is a dogged determination to get at the truth about nuclear deterrence, to expose the policy’s shortcomings and, despite ‘lengthy but ultimately frustrating correspondence with the MoD’, to go on asking questions about the legal and moral implications of the Government’s position”

Further information:
Commander Forsyth’s website, www.whytrident.uk, is a valuable source of information which includes most of the text included in the book and further biographical materials.

Spokesman Books is the publishing imprint of the Bertrand Russell Peace Foundation. Lord
Russell established the Foundation in 1963 to continue his work for peace, human rights and social justice. See www.spokesmanbooks.com for further information

Purchase direct through www.whytrident.uk or from your favourite book retailer.

Climate Justice Now – End Militarism!

Militarism and War Cause Climate Destruction

XR Peace in Brighton, 29 August 2020

XR Peace is a movement within Extinction Rebellion that especially highlights the military causes and impacts of climate chaos. We take action for Peace, Disarmament, Human Rights, Real Security and Climate Justice.

Climate Justice and war have the same root causes as structural inequality, racism and violence against women. They are the consequences of military-industrial systems of unsustainable growth, profit, aggression and exploitation.

Armed conflict and weapons contribute to poverty and cause great misery and death. Refugees flee their homes. Climate chaos makes everything worse. When things go wrong, the most vulnerable are at greatest risk. Women and children inevitably pay the highest price.

In March 2020, as Covid-19 spread around the world, UN Secretary-General António Guterres called for a global ceasefire saying: “It is time to put armed conflict on lockdown and focus together on the true fight of our lives.”

That means working together locally and globally to tackle the climate emergency and build up everyone’s health, care and education services. We have to reduce all weapons and military budgets, and develop effective, nonviolent ways to share resources and resolve our conflicts together. Care work and sustainable jobs are Green jobs.

There is No Planet B – Protect the Home We Share

Climate Chaos and Nuclear Weapons Pose Huge Dangers to our Environment and Security Every Day

Around $100 billion per year is spent on 13,400 nuclear weapons held by 9 nuclear states.

Detonating just a few of these nuclear WMD would add catastrophically to climate destruction and cause billions of initial survivors to die. Not only of radiation sickness, but of starvation all over the world.

The Greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions of UK weapons production and military spending in 2018 was 11 million tonnes of CO2 equivalent, as calculated by Scientists for Global Responsibility. BAE Systems produced 30% of these annual UN military-related emissions.

Make Urgent Changes Now to Create Real Security, Before it’s too late

  • Rebel for Life, Peace and Climate Justice
  • End Militarism and develop effective peace-building ways and means to resolve conflict among people and nations.
  • Reduce our Carbon footprints, eg through local and national Green New Deal policies, practices and economic steps to create sustainable jobs and to limit and share the resources we need.
  • Boycott and divest from all companies that enable, develop, make or sell weapons. Instead support ban treaties like the 2017 Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons.

[Download the flyer: CLIMATE JUSTICE NOW – END MILITARISM (Sept 2020) Militarism and War Cause Climate Destruction (pdf)]

We Want to Live: UK Rebellion 1st September 2020

The Rebellion Goes to Parliament

Waterloo Bridge, Parliament in background, London 19 March 2019. Photo credit

On 1st September the UK Parliament starts re-sitting after the summer: so Extinction Rebellion UK are going to make sure they start anew with justice, care and life at the heart of it.

From the 1st XR will peacefully disrupt the UK Parliament in London, carrying out pressure building actions over two weeks, until they back the Climate and Ecological Emergency Bill and prepare for crisis with a National Citizens’ Assembly.

The Rebellion will not just be focused on London though. Rebels will also join us in disruption of Cardiff and Manchester. These rebellions are open to all!

Find out how to engage and be a part of the Rebellion

We Want to Live: Climate Not Trident – CND’s August Bank Holiday weekend action

XR Peace are unable to participate as a movement within XR for this Rebellion – But XR Peace individuals are encouraged to get involved by forming their own autonomous groups or with other XR groups attending the Rebellion.

September Rebellion Facebook Event

XR Peace in Brighton, 29 August 2020

Healing Not Killing – 75 years since the atomic bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki

REPORT OF THE 2020 INTERNATIONAL PEACE FAST IN KNIGHTON

As part of Trident Ploughshares and XR Peace, 2 women (Angie Zelter and Lyn Gardenchild), fasted over 4 days to grieve and commemorate the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

They prepared 4 exhibition boards with information about the bombings, the 9 nuclear weapon states, the Treaty to Prohibit Nuclear Weapons, XR Peace and the impact of the military on climate chaos.

On each of the 4 days the boards, banners, and tables for leaflets and crane making were set up at 7.30 a.m. and then taken down at 6 p.m. Social distancing was adhered to although family clusters were closer. More than 50 different people visited the fast to view the exhibition, take part in the workshops or play music. Some people attending fasted for a day or missed a meal in solidarity and £188.80 was raised for the Knighton Food Bank.

The opening ceremony on Thursday 6th August at 8,15 a.m. was attended by around 13 people and there were readings from the Hiroshima Hibakusha and a bell from Hiroshima was rung.

Tod (on violin) and Camilla (on accordion) played for an hour while the knitting of white poppies began. This was followed by Baptist Minister Rev.Kevin Dare leading a workshop entitled ‘Is there any real hope for peace?’ We concluded that there was! He was joined by other local ministers representing the Church of Wales (Rev. Petra Goodband) and the Catholic Church (Father Jerome) and between them they led Prayers for Peace.

The atmosphere of the fast was lovely, calm and welcoming. At 3 p.m. Penny Rosenthal led a workshop on Maslow’s pyramid on the constituents of security and people joined in making themselves heard even over the very loud traffic noises.

Friday 7th August found the knitters fast at work and a young family came along and the father bought 2 of the poppies for his children. Christine (on whistle) along with Tod (on violin) made the time pass very pleasantly and intrigued passers by. The morning workshop led by John Goodband was fairly technical and explored the peaceful uses of radiation in cancer treatment, ending with a plea for just a fraction of the money spent on Trident to pay for more healing equipment.

The afternoon workshop led by Angie Zelter was on the impact of climate change on our security. The participants told us of the changes in climate they had observed locally and in the world at large and came up with lots of suggestions on how our local environment would be made more resilient and secure. Shadows were chalked on the ground – many people were unfamiliar with this tradition that symbolizes the shadows found on pavements in Hiroshima – the only remains of the people burnt into the ground by the heat of the explosion.

Saturday 8th August the peace crane making started really early and 3 strings of cranes were hung in the branches of the pin oak that was scattering us with beautiful flattened acorns. Charlie (on guitar) played for us, despite a badly cut thumb, and was then joined by John (who drummed on the guitar case and the Hiroshima bell).

Rev. Petra Goodband then gave a workshop giving us an insight into what a variety of different faiths said about nuclear weapons. Most outlawed indiscriminate weapons that killed civilians.

The afternoon workshop, led by Nandita Dowson on the Israeli annexation of Palestinian lands was very informative and lively and engendered much discussion.

Nagasaki day, 9th August, began quietly with Camilla (on accordion) and Chris (on flute).
11.01 a.m. began with John drumming. About 16 people gathered in a socially distanced circle to hear about the Nagasaki tragedy, a song was sung, a poem read, tears were shed.

But the good news was shared that on Hiroshima Day, 3 more States ratified the The U.N. Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons – Ireland, Nigeria, and Niue – and on this Nagasaki day Saint Kitts and Nevis also ratified. There are therefore now 44 States Parties.
There are only another 6 needed for the Treaty to come into force. We ended with a socially distanced group hug.

Webinar: Climate change and the Military

What are the links between the military and climate change?

How is campaigning for the environment linked to the campaign for Nuclear Disarmament?

How can we build successful campaigns as we lift out of the Covid Crisis?

Join XR Peace founder, Angie Zelter in conversation with Marine turned war-abolitionist Brian Jones, anti-nuclear and environmental activist David Collins, Nobel Peace Prize winner Rebecca Johnson and Quaker, feminist and peace activist Janet Fenton as they discuss the links between war, climate and energy.

Co-hosted by XR PEACE

Nuclear Weapons in COVID Times: Deadly Threats to Lives, Health and Security

On 13 May 2020, while Britain was in lockdown, nuclear warheads were taken on public roads from the UK’s Atomic Weapons Establishment (AWE) at Burghfield and Aldermaston in Berkshire, England, to Coulport in Scotland, driving past Oxford, Birmingham, Manchester and Glasgow.

[download print version] [download with links]

The nuclear convoy (snapped by XR Peace members in Nukewatch) broke lockdown rules to drop off warheads intended for US Trident missiles on UK’s nuclear powered submarines at Faslane, Her Majesty’s Naval Base (HMNB) Clyde. The government’s desire to keep deploying nuclear WMD is hardly a necessity or “good justification” for putting the NHS and British people at more risk if there were an accident.

Britain makes and deploys nuclear weapons and thereby faces especially high risks of nuclear accidents and use. Far from being a “deterrent that keeps us safe”, if the nuclear weapons carried on just one UK nuclear submarine were detonated, the impacts on the whole world would be devastating. Any survivors would face the horrors of climate chaos, nuclear winter, radiation sickness and mass famine.

NO SAFE HANDS FOR NUCLEAR BOMBS

Sending nuclear weapons around England and Scotland is the height of folly, especially in these Covid Times.

Nuclear weapons and power threaten our security, now more than ever

As the Covid-19 pandemic ravages our economy, destroys tens of thousands of lives and jobs, and stretches our NHS and frontline services to breaking point, we cannot afford the extra burden that nuclear weapons add to our emergency services. So why is the Government carrying on with making further nuclear weapons and submarines, with a price tag over £200 billion?

Covid-19 piles up the dangers already connected with nuclear activities. The navy, including HMNB Clyde at Faslane, is badly hit by coronavirus infections. Already struggling under regulatory “special measures” due to years of safety problems, AWE Aldermaston and Burghfield pose even more risks on skeleton staffing. In Cumbria, Barrow, where “Dreadnought” nuclear submarines are being built by BAE Systems, and Sellafield nuclear plant are also struggling with high rates of infection.

The Covid-19 pandemic reminds us of the fragility of our lives, families and countries. Accidents happen, as shown by the Chernobyl and Fukushima nuclear disasters. US pilots dropped nuclear bombs by mistake on NATO allies Greenland and Spain some years ago, causing serious plutonium contamination. Human error, miscalculations and irresponsible leaders have brought the world to the brink of nuclear war at least 13 times since 1960.

BLACK LIVES MATTER

We support the Black Lives Matter protests against the horrific murder of George Floyd by an armed white policeman in Minneapolis, who used his knee to choke the life out of this unarmed Black man, filmed for over 8 minutes. Several other police officers stood by and did nothing to help Floyd, who gasped over and over again “I can’t breathe” until he lost consciousness and died.

The calls for Justice take place against the backdrop of personal and institutional racism and attitudes of white supremacy that have poisoned the whole history of the United States of America. These Black Lives Matter protests connect unmistakably with the racist-colonialist histories of our own countries as well, that have caused untold human misery for centuries of slavery, rape and lynching, and which continue even now through institutional inequality and discrimination, and the hate and fear embedded in white supremacist narratives.

XR Peace was established last year to highlight the links between the Climate Emergency and military-industrial frameworks, objectives and profiteering connected with weapons and war. The Black Lives Matter movement calls for Action to end racism, Justice for George Floyd and all the other Black Lives destroyed by racism, and for fundamental changes to tackle inequality, prejudice, and abuses of power by police and others in authority. Their demands directly connect with the peace and justice work that we do.

When George Floyd was murdered last week, his six year old daughter lost her father. That’s the human story. The continuation of racist-colonialist military-industrial warmongering and environmental destruction is the shameful history that has brought the whole world to the brink of extinction.

Today – and every day – we must walk shoulder to shoulder with our Black Sisters and Brothers in our lives and campaigns for peace and justice.

Ban Nuclear Weapons : Prevent Climate Catastrophe

Before the coronavirus crisis, XR peace planned to be in the streets from 1st June to raise awareness with our next Rebellion for Climate Security, Peace and Justice. To protect our health, care and frontline workers, as well as all vulnerable people (including ourselves and our families ), we’re putting our protests online for the time being, sharing info and other relevant resources.

Here is the fourth leaflet in our series, which highlights the importance of the 2017 Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW), a new, multilateral, UN-negotiated treaty that bans the use, production and deployment of nuclear weapons and requires their total abolition. With over three fifths of the UN General Assembly already supporting the Ban Treaty and only 13 states parties to go before 50 governments complete their national processes for ratification, the TPNW is set to enter into full international legal force very soon. As more states join, the Treaty parties will establish new systems to eliminate the weapons safely and implement the whole Treaty.

XR Peace calls on the UK government to sign this UN Treaty now, take its Trident-based nuclear weapons system off deployment and work with the rest of the world to eliminate all nuclear dangers.

[Print version with links; Print version without links]

BAN NUCLEAR WEAPONS AND PREVENT NUCLEAR WAR AND CLIMATE CATASTROPHE

All wars and militarism undermine our security and harm our climate. Nuclear weapons and war cause particularly horrendous suffering and environmental harm, including nuclear winter and mass famine. To prevent this, the 2017 Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons was negotiated in the UN and adopted in July 2017 by 122 states with just one vote against and one abstention. As of today, this Nuclear Ban Treaty has 37 states parties and 81 signatory states. The UK and certain other nuclear armed states have not yet signed. Instead they are trying to enhance and build more nuclear weapons, causing huge risks to the whole world.

Help us abolish nuclear weapons before they abolish us

It is 75 years after the cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki were flattened by the first two nuclear weapons in 1945. Those “small” atomic bombs killed more than 230,000 people. Over 100,000 were killed instantly in the intense fireballs. Then over weeks and months, many more died from burns, blast injuries and in terrible pain from radiation sickness. The atomic bombs had killed and badly injured 90% of the doctors and nurses in Hiroshima and Nagasaki, so it was impossible for local services to provide humanitarian help for the thousands of dead and dying.

Setsuko Thurlow was a 13 year old schoolgirl in Hiroshima when the US atomic bomb nicknamed “Little Boy” destroyed her city on 6th August 1945, killing almost all her friends and some family members. She represented the International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons (at the 2017 Nobel Peace Prize ceremony) and spoke at the United Nations about the fear and pain of that experience and the terrible suffering she witnessed, she would remember: “each person who died had a name; each person had someone who loved them”.

Since 1945, the world has been brought close to nuclear war several times due to leadership mistakes and computer errors. We can’t risk more mistakes with nuclear weapons.

Just a fraction of today’s nuclear weapons would contaminate the Earth and cause “nuclear winter“. The mushroom clouds from incinerated cities would disrupt the world’s climate systems and destroy agriculture, natural ecosystems and food resources. Global famine and disease would follow, killing an estimated two billion people.

The “Trident” missiles on just one UK nuclear armed submarine are all it would take to cause climate devastation and nuclear winter.

Despite widespread support in Britain and around the world, the UK government boycotted the UN’s multilateral negotiations and is refusing even to take preparatory steps to comply. Instead, it is pouring billions of pounds into upgrading UK nuclear weapons and submarines.

The 2017 Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons is important because it stigmatises nuclear weapons as inhumane and abhorrent, comprehensively bans these weapons of mass destruction, and then provides legal provisions that governments and multilateral institutions will be able to build on to eliminate all nuclear arsenals safely and securely.

Unlike other nuclear treaties, the TPNW applies to everyone, and clearly prohibits developing, testing, manufacturing, stockpiling, acquiring and possessing nuclear armaments. It bans stationing, installing and deploying nuclear weapons, and also outlaws actions that “assist, encourage or induce” anyone to commit any actions that are prohibited by the Treaty.

Already the Nuclear Ban Treaty is reducing the value of these WMD and diminishing the political power and status that some states and leaders have attached to nuclear arms for far too long.

When it enters into international legal force, which could be in 2020 or soon after, the Nuclear Ban Treaty will help to reduce nuclear risks while working to eliminate them completely. As a Treaty under International Humanitarian Law, the Nuclear Ban Treaty goes beyond the states that are currently reluctant to sign Many of its provisions can also be taken up and applied to nuclear-related activities of banks, investors, manufacturers, city officials, parliamentarians, decision-makers – and all of us!

Global Ceasefire Now!

Before the coronavirus crisis, XR peace planned to be in the streets from 1st June to raise awareness with our next Rebellion for Climate Security, Peace and Justice. To protect our health, care and frontline workers, as well as all vulnerable people (including ourselves and our families ), we’re putting our protests online with a series of leaflets and other relevant resources. Here is the third, which builds on the UN Secretary-General’s call for a Global Ceasefire and includes XR Peace’s five-point action plan to make it happen.

[Print version with links; Print version without links]

GLOBAL CEASEFIRE NOW!

SAVE LIVES, BUILD INTERNATIONAL SECURITY AND PEACE

On 23 March, as the Covid-19 coronavirus spread around the world, UN Secretary-General António Guterres called for a global ceasefire, saying: “End the sickness of war and fight the disease that is ravaging our world.  It starts by stopping the fighting everywhere.  Now.  That is what our human family needs, now more than ever.”

“Armed conflict rages on around the world.  The most vulnerable — women and children, people with disabilities, the marginalized and the displaced — pay the highest price.  They are also at the highest risk of suffering devastating losses from COVID-19… Refugees and others displaced by violent conflict are doubly vulnerable.”

Calling for diplomacy and dialogue to tackle the causes of conflict, Guterres referred to the “folly of war” and sounded the clarion call:

“It is time to put armed conflict on lockdown and focus together on the true fight of our lives. To warring parties, I say:  Pull back from hostilities.  Put aside mistrust and animosity.  Silence the guns, stop the artillery, end the airstrikes.”

NO-ONE SHOULD PROFIT FROM VIOLENCE AND DESTRUCTION

A Global Ceasefire is necessary not only in Covid times, but for our future. To make this sustainable, legal and political steps must be taken not only to disarm and demilitarise warmongering groups and states, but also to build greater security, peaceful relations and cooperative institutions at local, regional, national and international levels.

FROM CEASEFIRE TO BUILDING PEACE:

  • Deep and irreversible disarmament: disarm the combatants; remove, dismantle and eliminate weapons and delivery systems, from guns and “small arms” to bombs and launchers, from grenades to nuclear weapons; use existing international law, treaties and agreements where appropriate; and negotiate further disarmament agreements where needed.
  • Peace must be built by people on the ground, framed with humanitarian and feminist rights and principles for good governance and the full and equal participation of women, who suffer dispropropionate impacts from the use of weapons, including sexual and physical violence. Mediation and reconciliation may also be necessary.
  • Address the roots of conflict, which include climate chaos and the destruction of forests, homes, and resources by greedy aggressors with geo-political, military-industrial or extractivist motivations; pressures and rivalries for land and water; space to grow food and live on; colonialist and patriachal histories that feed religious extremism, fragmentation of societies, violence against women and people with different ethnic origins; corruption; bad governance…
  • Demobilise and rehabilitate all combatants and put in place systems for retraining, education, counselling, care and support into peaceful jobs, with special support for refugees and children who may have been coerced into fighting and/or sexual slavery.
  • Tackle the causes and demilitarise relations among conflicting parties and economic factors that fuel conflict, locally and internationally, with priority given to ending the arms sales locally and the global arms trade, including production, transfers and proliferation of deadly weapons from predatory states and arms manufacturers.

World Day for Child Victims of Aggression

Before the coronavirus crisis, XR peace planned to be in the streets from 1st June to raise awareness with our next Rebellion for Climate Security, Peace and Justice. To protect our health, care and frontline workers, as well as all vulnerable people (including ourselves and our families ), we’re putting our protests online with a series of leaflets and other relevant resources. Here is the second, which recognises that June 4th is “World Day for Child Victims of Aggression”. Children are most at risk of violence where there are men with weapons, from militias and armed police to domestic violence and war.

[Print version with links; Print version without links]

MILITARISM IS A BIG CAUSE OF CLIMATE DESTRUCTION AND VIOLENCE AGAINST CHILDREN

Millions of children live in conflict, with terrifying threats of physical and sexual violence every day. They see friends and family killed and injured. Some are also injured, raped, or trafficked into sexual slavery, unwanted marriage and pregnancy. Sexual violence is often used to humiliate a population and force people to flee their homes.

Militarism and war add massively to climate destruction. And environmental destruction and climate chaos have become major causes of violent conflicts over land, resources, food and water.

Refugee children are most vulnerable.

VIOLENCE AND WAR DON’T OBEY HUMANITARIAN RULES

The rules of war prohibit the indiscriminate use of weapons, the targeting of civilians and attacks on schools and hospitals. Nuclear weapons are still targeted at cities full of children, from Londo­­n and Moscow to Delhi and Islamabad. Every day, in conflicts around the world, women and children are killed by guns, grenades and explosive weapons, which are often used in heavily populated areas. Landmines blow up when children are playing in fields near their homes. Cluster munitions look like plastic toys, till they explode in a child’s face.

As noted by UNICEF:

“No method of warfare has been off-limits, no matter how deadly for children: Indiscriminate attacks on schools, hospitals and other civilian infrastructure, abductions, child recruitment, besiegement, abuse in detention and denial of humanitarian assistance…”

DO YOU WANT TO KEEP CHILDREN SAFE?

In the real world, war doesn’t obey humanitarian rules. Neither does climate chaos, a major consequence of military-industrial activities. We have to tackle the climate emergency, support the UN call for a Global Ceasefire, and stop those who make, sell and use weapons.

CONTACT  xrpeace@gn.apc.org