Thales

12th Nov 2021 – XR Peace response to Thales letter [download pdf]

25th Oct 2021 – Thales letter to XR Peace following recent XR Peace visits to arms dealers’ and military locations in Glasgow: [download pdf].

11th Nov 2021 – XR Peace letter to Thales during a visit at the COP26 Glasgow. [download]

11th Nov 2021 – to illustrate the ongoing corrupt behaviour of Thales, XR Peace was sent the following information:-

Thales investigated by the National Financial Prosecutor’s Office (PNF) [Translated from the French]

An investigation by the National Financial Prosecutor’s Office (PNF) was opened at the end of 2020 into the group headed by Patrice Caine for suspicions of “corruption” and “influence peddling”. It concerns facts reported internally by an export manager of Thales SIX GTS on the conversion of one of its executives to the United Nations, a client of the defence group.

Already implicated in the Jacob Zuma bribery case currently on trial in South Africa, the Thales group is once again caught up in suspicions of corruption. According to our information, the National Financial Prosecutor’s Office (PNF) opened a preliminary investigation in Paris in December 2020 for “corruption” and “influence peddling” in a new case concerning one of its former employees.

A dual role at the UN?
The Parisian magistrates are more specifically interested in the two-step transfer of an ex-employee of the French arms firm from Thales SIX GTS to the United Nations (UN). The New York-based organisation is one of the major clients – as are NATO and the European Union (EU) – of this subsidiary specialising in secure information systems for the armed forces and headed by Marc Darmon.

A former export manager of the Support and Customer Services division of Thales SIX GTS, now headed by Alexis Dalem, suspects the employee under her responsibility of having played a strange double game with the UN. The latter would have joined the international organisation thanks to his reservist’s hat while keeping his salary paid by Thales, without informing the UN, his new employer. Then, after applying for a new position at the UN in 2018, he allegedly asked for “a stipend in return for the information useful to Thales’ business that he would provide once in office”, according to a message sent by his superior to the group’s ethics department.

In this March 2019 email, this Gennevilliers-based executive notes that the employee’s departure should have been in the form of a resignation and not a dismissal, which is much more advantageous as it gives the right to compensation. Still according to the terms reported in this report, the transfer from Thales to the UN saw this dismissal as a “good handshake” on the occasion of a departure paradoxically synonymous with future good and loyal service.

The magistrates are therefore examining these elements and will have to determine whether they are proven and likely to be related to influence peddling and corruption. According to our information, the referral to the PNF followed a message from the French Anti-Corruption Agency (AFA). Of the 298 alerts submitted to the AFA in 2020, this was the only one to be sent to the PNF that year on the basis of Article 40 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. This case was “deemed sufficiently serious”, AFA wrote, without naming the case, in its 2020 annual activity report.

With this investigation, the PNF judges are going behind the scenes of the most sensitive arms contracts. The former Thales executive had key accounts (UN, European Union, NATO) in the Systems Support and User Services sector within her scope. It was thus credited for its involvement in the file of a sovereign data centre in Iraq, the renewal of the Cisaf contract in Afghanistan for Nato, or the winning, against Airbus, of the contract for the supply of secure communications services for the military planning and control capability (MPCC) and the EU training mission (EUTM) in Mali. In 2016, Thales also won a major surveillance and security contract for the United Nations Multidimensional Integrated Stabilisation Mission in Mali (Minusma). In 2017, this mission also planned to study the implementation of communications systems to strengthen the protection of the force. The French electronics and defence group was expecting a future endorsement in 2019 after successful business development actions.

Thales’ compliance tested by the PNF
The opening of this PNF investigation and the internal handling of the episode raise questions about the processes put forward by Thales on the anti-corruption front. The group had carried out a major facelift in 2019 to adapt to the requirements of the Sapin 2 law of December 2016 on transparency and the fight against corruption. Procedures relating to the prevention of corruption, as well as an assessment of the situation of its customers, suppliers, intermediaries and other partners were launched.Thales had then deployed more than one hundred “compliance officers”, now placed under the leadership of Jean-Baptiste Siproudhis, Thales’s ethics director who arrived in May 2019 from Atos. The firm had also insisted on training 10 000 of its employees in the fight against corruption. The results of this internal reorganisation of compliance could be put into perspective in the event of criminal proceedings. The firm has in fact closed the two alerts launched by its former executive. In February 2020, the group’s whistleblower monitoring committee deemed the case to be closed. It argued that since the “situation denounced had not persisted”, it would not give rise to “other measures or initiatives”.

Export manager dismissed
The internal investigation had conceded blunders in setting up the sales organisation and led to formal written reminders in July 2019 to several senior managers. But in its integrated 2020 report, Thales had been more categorical in its defence. The group said that the four professional alerts received in 2019 relating to allegations of corruption had “all been closed, as internal investigations have confirmed the absence of proven facts of corruption”.
Far from closing the case, this internal classification marked the beginning of a tug of war between the group and the former export manager of its subsidiary. The firm fired this executive in May 2020. The latter presented her eviction as a retaliatory measure directly linked to her warning. For its part, the electronics and defence group invoked major relationship difficulties and employee testimonies reporting suffering at work in order to justify her dismissal for real and serious reasons.

The former employee lost before the summary proceedings section of the Nanterre labour tribunal, then before the Versailles court of appeal. She has now appealed to the Court of Cassation. During the procedure, however, she received support from Claire Hédon, the rights defender. In a decision of October 2020, the independent authority considers that this dismissal is a continuation of the difficulties linked to the denunciation made by the former Thales executive. The rights defender considers that the latter should have benefited from the protection offered by the Sapin 2 law to whistleblowers. The former Thales SIX GT executive is also supported by the House of Whistleblowers, an association that brings together trade unions and NGOs, and internally by the UNSA trade union. The employees’ organisation has pointed out a serious flaw in the internal procedures. The interview for the dismissal of the export manager was conducted by her line manager, even though she was directly involved in the whistleblowing.

Clarification from the editors on 07/10/21: We indicated that “the export manager lost before the summary proceedings section of the Nanterre labour tribunal”. It should be noted that it is indeed her summary proceedings before the industrial tribunal, a procedure that allows for an accelerated handling of the case, that was rejected, as was the appeal of this summary proceedings. The seizure on the merits has therefore not yet been examined at first instance by the social court.