Tackling global security risks in the second Trump era [Rethinking Security]

The following is an abstract from an article by Dr Stuart Parkinson on 13 January 2025 from https://rethinkingsecurity.org.uk/2025/01/13/tackling-global-security-risks-in-the-second-trump-era/

The return of Donald Trump to the US presidency undermines efforts to tackle urgent global security risks such as nuclear weapons and climate change. Dr Stuart Parkinson gives an overview of the problems and assesses how best to respond.

Global risks have been increasing for years. To name but some of the most extreme are the climate crisis, the potential for nuclear war, the breaching of numerous planetary boundaries, the increase in extreme inequality and poverty, the growing number of ‘conventional’ wars, disruptive technologies, and disease pandemics. Most, if not all, have a security dimension.

There’s plenty of evidence that the election of Donald Trump as US president for the second time will undermine progress in tackling virtually all of these.

This article focuses on two leading examples – the risk of nuclear war and the climate crisis – to highlight both the threats from Trump and the numerous opportunities to blunt his negative impact. One key element is the role of scientific community…

The Climate Crisis

Global climate change is already reaching critical levels. Climate scientists estimate that global carbon emissions will likely exceed the level necessary to breach the 1.5°C temperature target – as specified in the 2015 Paris Climate Agreement (PCA) – as early as 2027. Climate change-induced extreme weather is already wreaking havoc around the world – in the form of heatwaves, droughts, wildfires, major storms, floods, and crop failures – and things are set to get much worse. The probability is growing that we will soon pass critical ‘climate tipping points’, where change becomes rapid and irreversible. This includes die-back of the world’s coral reefs and the Amazon rainforest, melting of major ice sheets, and changes to major ocean currents. The impacts will be felt most acutely by the most vulnerable human communities, and are already contributing to a mass extinction of animals and plants.

Trump – a self-confessed climate denier – is therefore one of the last people the world needs as president of the world’s largest economy right now. His policies include withdrawing the United States from the PCA and dismantling national low carbon energy programmes. He supports an expansion of oil production in areas like the Alaskan Arctic, and a resumption of US exports of high-carbon liquified natural gas. New tariffs on imported goods are likely to push up the prices of low carbon technologies such as solar panels. His pick for Energy Secretary is Chris Wright, an oil and gas industry executive who endorses Trump’s extreme views and policies.

However, Trump will still face significant obstacles in trying to derail the low carbon transition now underway in the United States, let alone internationally.

  1. Competitiveness of renewables

Let’s start with energy. US coal use has been falling rapidly since its peak in 2007, due to poor economics and less polluting alternatives. Even during Trump’s first term, consumption fell 25%,[ii] despite his claims to support the industry. The latest data shows that consumption has fallen 55% below the peak. Likewise, US electricity generation from renewable sources expanded 34% despite Trump’s lack of support during his first term.[iii] Again, this growth followed the overarching trend, with cost playing a critical factor. The favourable economics of especially wind and solar power – with an increasing role for energy storage technologies – is improving year by year, meaning fossil fuels are likely to be replaced even more rapidly in future years.

  1. State and local activism

Indeed, much climate-related policy is decided and implemented at state level in the United States, and hence Trump’s ability to interfere will be even more limited. 23 states – representing over 50% of the US population – now have carbon reduction targets, with most aiming for net zero emissions by 2050 at the latest. President Biden’s Inflation Reduction Act put in place many support mechanisms for climate action, creating large numbers of jobs, so states that have benefitted are likely to oppose these changes both within Congress and through the courts.

  1. Price impacts of tariffs

Trump’s plans to bring in tariffs for imported goods are likely to have mixed effects on climate action. While there are justified concerns that these will slow the uptake of cleaner technologies such as solar panels and electric vehicles, there is widespread agreement among economists that the tariffs will lead to significant price rises for all US consumers. This will likely decrease consumption of a wide range of goods and energy use more broadly – and could well bring down carbon emissions.

  1. International cooperation and action

The response of other nations to Trump’s climate-related policies will be also critical. It is essential that other major economies quickly increase co-operation over their climate-related policies and research programmes. This will, for example, help enable them to submit much more ambitious climate targets to the UN by the next deadline in February. There are numerous international alliances focused on expanding renewables, improving energy efficiency, and cutting methane emissions, fossil fuel subsidies, and deforestation. Support for these needs to be strengthened. One important aspect is to improve trade between neighbouring nations, which will help shorten supply chains and hence reduce emissions. Measures targeting fossil fuel corporations and elite polluters could yield particularly large reductions.

The COP29 climate negotiations in early November – carried out in the shadow of Trump’s election – showed that nations could still reach agreement on numerous initiatives, ranging from international climate finance to the expansion of energy storage. However, ambition is still not close to where it needs to be. Climate-friendly governments, campaigners, and scientists will need to keep up the pressure for much stronger action.

While the chances of keeping global temperature change below 1.5°C may be vanishing fast, no effort should be spared to prevent every 0.1°C rise above that target. Each fraction of a degree would still represent huge numbers of lives lost and ecosystems devastated. Indeed, it is also essential that other wealthier nations increase their funding of climate adaptation measures in vulnerable communities.

Scientific evidence

Underpinning the dangers that Trump poses for global security risks is his disdain for scientific evidence and his willingness to spread disinformation.

One especially serious concern here is that he will start to dismantle US government scientific bodies and research programmes which don’t suit his agenda. This could also interrupt data collection on key issues from health to arms control to environmental protection. During his first term, he cut funding for NASA’s satellite-based Earth observation programmes – which are important for climate change research. This time around he could end the Global Change Research Program and dismantle the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). He could also cut crucial US funding for UN bodies, such as the UN Environment Programme (UNEP), World Health Organisation (WHO), and UN Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO).

Again, it is essential for others – whether they be national governments, US bodies at the state level, or independently funded scientific organisations – to step into any voids as far as possible, whether by providing additional funds or hosting R&D programmes. We must also support individual scientists who resist attacks on evidence gathering. We cannot allow the incoming Trump government to subvert the research and data upon which robust policy-making depends.

While the situation looks grim on many fronts, there is much that can be done to reduce the negative impacts of a new Trump-led government – and the time to act is now.